YES

A distraction

It would reduce social interaction among children as most of them would be busy making friends on Facebook rather than in real life. Second, it would distract pupils during class. Lastly, it would lead to discrimination between students as some would have costlier gadgets than others.

Anuj Derick George

St. Xavier’s Collegiate School, Calcutta

Money minded

Gadgets in school will only lead to students boasting about their status by showing off their gadgets. Their minds would be too busy concentrating on the gadgets others have rather than on studies. It would make them materialistic. They would waste time thinking about the features of gadgets even during solving equations or reading Shakespeare. The competition would then be in the display of gadgets, not in academics.

Brishti Ghosh Choudhury

Holy Home, Serampore, Hooghly

Teachers redundant

If students start using gadgets in school for studying, there’s little scope of a teacher in class. Allowing gadgets in school would also be equivalent to giving an open invitation to distraction. It will make students dull and hamper their thinking skills because they will grow dependant on gadgets rather than utilising their own abilities.

Aamyrah Khurram

Loreto Day School, Elliot Road, Calcutta

NO

Greatest gift

Electronic gadgets are one of the greatest gifts of science. They can be used by anybody. In school too, they can be put to different uses — such as getting help by googling, as a support for students with special needs and providing easy access to information. If gadgets are put to proper use, it will only enhance the education process.

Ditiya Kumar

St. Anthony’s High School, Calcutta

Help the weak

Gadgets are an innovative way to study for weak students as they can avail these resources repeatedly, which is not possible with traditional teaching methods. Also, it is a one-time investment and does not require expending money regularly on things such as coaching centres, reference books and so on. Thereby, it will also help poor children.

Shah Fahad Azmi

Syamaprasad College, Calcutta

Next issue: Colleges and universities should have student uniforms Have a strong view on this? Write in with your phone number, address, school/college and year to telegraphyou@gmail.com. The best answers for the motion and the most cogent arguments against it will be printed here