NO

Always about extravagance

I cannot fully agree with the statement. Culture is not a constant thing and cultural traditions cannot be definite. Take, for example, the Durga Pujas started by zamindars. Durga’s idol would be adorned with heavy, gold jewellery. There would be rivalry between the zamindars on who could splurge more, and were considered a splurge by the common people even then. So, extravagance has been part of festivities for long. What is considered splurge today might be considered cultural tradition some decades later.

Shruti Laha, Class XI, D.A.V. Model School, Durgapur

Provide employment

Nowadays, people are stressed at their workplaces, students are stressed about studies. Festivals act like medicine for such stressful events. Moreover, many poor and unemployed people get some work due to the festivals. A festive season is supposed to bring a smile to every face, so it is okay to spend money on something that brings the smiles. And cultural traditions are maintained along with a sprinkle of modernism.

Shreyasee Dutta, First year, St. Xavier’s College, Calcutta

Warm gatherings foster bonds

On the outside, festivals today might seem to be more about splurge than traditions, a deeper look will reveal a different thing. They are about warm gatherings and get-togethers, upholding traditional values and happy memories thereafter. Thus, they sustain societies, making bonds stronger.

Smiti Wal Sen,B.Ed., Loreto College, Calcutta

Bring people together

Festivals are always meant to be a tryst or an act of uniting different types of people. They act as stress relievers. They also provide an opportunity to reduce friction and bring estranged friends and relatives together. Nothing brings people together like festivals do. Festivals are a way to celebrate glorious heritage, culture and traditions. It has always been that.

Pragati Khan,

Second year, Asutosh College, Calcutta

YES

No time for bodhon

Durga Puja, Diwali, Navratri, Id, Christmas, all provide us with the opportunity to splurge, egged on by bumper sales, jaw-dropping discounts and other offers. Earlier, pandals were simple, not theme oriented. Now, the organisers compete and spend more on pandals and festivities rather than paying attention to rituals. During Durga Puja, the faces of the idols are supposed to be covered till bodhon on Sashthi. But now they can be seen from Tritiya or Chaturthi itself! Immersion too does not happen on Dashami.

Riddhi Deb, First year, The Future Institute of Engineering and Management, Calcutta

Click-happy

The youth today have little or no idea about what a festival is all about, why a particular festival is celebrated. More so because they are so engrossed in capturing the moments on camera rather than being part of any of the rituals. They are unaware of the cultural traditions and that these should be imbibed as festivals are not merely about splurging.

Hiya Agarwala, Class XII, Mahadevi Birla World Academy, Calcutta

About showing off

I totally agree. Nowadays, festivals seem more like a competition. It is about who can spend more money. People want to show off their standard of living and want to be better than others. Before a festival, they start shopping for clothes, accessories, house decor and so on, even if all those things are not needed. They have forgotten to come together and celebrate the traditions.

Krisha Mittal, Class IX, The Heritage School, Calcutta

Next issue: ALL VEHICLES SHOULD RUN ON ELECTRICITY

Have a strong view on this? Write in with your phone number, address, school/college and year to telegraphyou@gmail.com. The best answers will be printed here