MY KOLKATA EDUGRAPH
ADVERTISEMENT
regular-article-logo Friday, 22 November 2024

Letters to the Editor: Camels edge towards extinction in India

Readers write in from Calcutta, Faridabad, Hooghly, Howrah, Bengaluru, Chennai and Mumbai

The Editorial Board Published 12.07.24, 07:20 AM
Soumitra Chatterjee, Siddhartha Chatterjee, Santosh Datta in Rajasthan shooting for bengali film Sonar Kella.

Soumitra Chatterjee, Siddhartha Chatterjee, Santosh Datta in Rajasthan shooting for bengali film Sonar Kella. Sourced by the Telegraph

Shipwrecked

Sir — The ship of the desert might soon become a memory for Indians. Camels, once a staple source of income for many Indians, are edging towards extinction in India. Not only is the sale or export of camels restricted to only a few places in India but camel rearing has also become unsustainable and expensive. Although the Centre has tried to arrest the drastic fall in camel trade, reviving the population of camels, which were once ubiquitous in Rajasthan, will be a difficult enterprise. One wonders what the iconic film, Sonar Kella, would be like had it not featured Lalmohanbabus breathless chase on camel-back. In that film, camels had saved the day. But can we save them?

ADVERTISEMENT

Diya Ghosh, Calcutta

Blood spills

Sir — Terrorists ambushed an army convoy in Jammu’s Kathua district, resulting in the death of five soldiers of Garhwal Rifles (“Kathua ambush kills 5 soldiers”, July 9). This is the second militant attack in the region in two days and the sixth in a month. Kashmir Tigers, a shadow outfit of the Pakistan-based terror outfit, Jaish-e-Mohammad, has claimed responsibility for the attack. Despite a hefty military budget, Indian soldiers continue to perish. The Jammu and Kashmir director-general of police, R.R. Swain, recently set a deadline of three months for ending militancy in Jammu. A similar promise made by the Union minister, Amit Shah, last year remains unfulfilled. The saffron brigade must act upon its poll plank of ‘ghar mein ghus ke marenge’.

Bidyut Kumar Chatterjee, Faridabad

Sir — It is heartbreaking that five army personnel were killed and several injured in a terrorist ambush in Kathua. Inadequate surveillance and infrequent anti-terrorist operations are responsible for this. The attack has exposed the gaps in the Centre’s claims regarding Jammu and Kashmir’s security. It needs to take stock of the situation and ensure the safety of both the army and the citizens.

Jayanta Datta, Hooghly

Sir — At least five army personnel have been injured in the terrorist attack in Kathua. It is worrying that the number of ambushes is on the rise in new zones of Jammu and Kashmir. The militants have been able to penetrate deeper into the country. The ammunition they use is usually imported from other nations. This is a link that must be examined.

Santi Pramanick, Howrah

Sir — Militancy is on the rise in Jammu and Kashmir (“No full stops on blood and bodybag terrain”, July 10). The latest of such attacks has claimed five lives. In­terestingly, militancy has shifted from the Kashmir Valley to Jammu in what is perhaps an attempt by both Pakistan and China to bog down Indian forces in three separate regions — Kashmir, Jammu, and Ladakh. Being engaged in Kash­mir will divert India’s attention from the Chinese forces in Ladakh.

N. Sadhasiva Reddy, Bengaluru

Sir — The death of five soldiers in Jammu is a matter of concern. The Centre’s claim of having control over militant activities seems to be a hogwash.

M.C. Vijay Shankar, Chennai

Wise decision

Sir — The Supreme Court has observed that the National Entrance-cum-Eligibility Test (Undergraduate) has been com­promised and sought status reports from the Centre, the Central Bureau of Investigation, and the National Testing Agency (“SC seeks leak report, but rider on retest”, July 9). When will the education ministry provide adequate reasons regarding the paper leak? The apex court has taken the sound decision of waiting to ascertain whether the leak was confined to a few exam centres or was more widespread. The culprits should be brought to book.

Arun Gupta, Calcutta

Sir — Cancelling the entire NEET (UG) because of a paper leak is unnecessary. This should be the last resort as the decision might affect the lives of over 23 lakh students who appeared for the examination. Some students are appealing for the removal of the NEET. Such a step will cause bigger problems.

A.P. Thiruvadi, Chennai

Strange words

Sir — The rules of grammar seem to have gone for a toss with students reproducing social media lingo on their answer sheets (“Colloquialisms worry teachers”, July 8). Words like ‘yup’ and ‘yeah’ are used by adults who already have a command over the language. The loss of the habit of reading beyond textbooks contributes to the lack of language skills among young people. The future of grammar looks bleak.

Anthony Henriques, Mumbai

Sir — Mastering the English language has always been a challenge for students. The ineffective method of teaching English in schools is to be blamed for this. Smartphones have now made children acquainted with the language of the new generation and, hence, the shift in their usage of English has become unavoidable.

Pratima Manimala, Howrah

Follow us on:
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT