The Indian Institute of Management- Ahmedabad (IIM-A) on Friday said it will demolish 14 of its dormitories designed by legendary American architect Louis Kahn, as they have become ‘unsafe’ for living. The institute said “dilapidation and structural deterioration” in the dorms have prompted them to make the decision.
It reasoned that these buildings had borne the brunt of time over the years, and had become beyond repair as it withstood a lot, including the 2001 earthquake and water seepages.
Kahn, a world-famous architect, had been invited to Ahmedabad by renowned scientist Vikram Sarabhai to design several buildings. IIM-A was one of the iconic buildings that was built by him in the 1960s.
In a letter to the alumni, IIM-A director Errol D'Souza shared photographs of the damaged conditions, which the buildings are in.
“We felt it necessary to keep you informed as we are the custodians of the Louis Kahn buildings that have the potential to inspire future generations. Over the past couple of decades, the buildings have undergone dilapidation and structural deterioration,” he said.
“The earthquake at the beginning of the millennium and water seepage through ageing and deterioration of the exposed brick walls has resulted in large cracks in the masonry and periodical detachments of it in fragments. They are unsafe for living,” he said.
“We have grappled with questions as to why we should presume that the past is not changeable and why we should assume that future generations will value things in exactly the same way that past generations have. We wondered if it is appropriate for us to colonise future perceptions of living spaces,” he added.
“It has not been easy to deal with the issues that have come up as we have attempted to restore these buildings,” D’Souza said in the 11-page letter.
“As is well-known that concrete encasing was not used by Kahn to protect the embedded reinforcement bars in the brickwork and that has resulted in rusting of the bars and cracks in the brickwork. The bricks used were not the best in class and had an in-built efflorescence,” said the letter.
“The bricks used by Kahn were what architects call second class bricks as per IS 3102-1971 with an average compressive strength of 4.89 N/sq mm and with in-built efflorescence,” the it said.
“The pointing that was used to hide the blunt edges of the bricks got damaged and allowed collection of water, which resulted in ingress into the masonry. The earthquake of 2001, among other things, posed challenges to the structural stability of the buildings,” it said.
“We have attempted to address these issues with the best team of conservation architects anyone could ask for- SNK (Somaya & Kalappa Consultants). We had invited international restoration consultants Peter Inskip and Stephen Gee to advise us and they suggested we first restore one building and then based on our findings we could proceed to take up further work in other buildings,” the letter added.
“We decided to restore Dorm 15 and the Library,” D’Souza said.
“Wherever cracks were found, they were stitched with stainless steel helical bars. Where the cracks were deep, face bricks were removed and fresh brick-work was done. In some cases, like the flat arches on the east facade of the library, they were completely redone with stainless steel reinforcement,” he said.
“After completion of the complex work, we were curious about the longevity of the buildings. We appointed an independent structural consultant, who opined that the compressive and tensile stresses in the walls exceed the limits as per the coda requirements of IS:1905-1987 and that the buildings are unsafe,” he said.
“After long deliberations, it was decided to commit to doing whatever it takes to restore the core of the Louis Kahn buildings, the library, the faculty wings, and the classroom complex and the dorms on the periphery of the system of buildings,” the director said.
“For the other dorms, however, it was decided to be guided by three imperatives: (1) functional needs, (2) cultural heritage, and (3) available resources,” he added.
“After much circumspection, we have decided to restore Dorms 16 to 18. Along with the restored Dorm 15 as you would recollect they constitute the periphery of the built campus and are the first buildings that persons who enter the campus see and understand along with the LKP and associated buildings as the grandeur associated with the work of Kahn,” he said.
“For the other dorms (1 to 14) that are in the inner core, we will invite architects from across the world to present us options as to how we should go about making new dorms,” D'Souza said.
