Yes
Only medicine
An old saying goes “spare the rod and spoil the child”. The modern belief system discards this notion. But if you look around, today’s children are more unruly, disobedient and disrespectful. I believe that parents should hit their children to help them become disciplined.
Saumili Mukherjji
Class XII, Auxilium Convent School, Bandel
Won’t repeat mistakes
Some children are mischievous, some are not. Parents should hit only those who don’t care to abide by their rules, just to bring them on the right track. These children will get a lesson and will hopefully learn to restrain themselves from making the same mistakes.
Bitan Basak
Class XII, Fulia Sikshaniketan High School, Phulia, Nadia
No
Many other ways
There are ample ways of instilling discipline. Hitting children makes rebels out of them. It also breaks their spirit and in certain cases hampers growth.
Harsh Nathani
Third year, The Bhawanipur Education Society College,
Calcutta
Adverse impact
Hitting children might have serious repercussions to the contrary. They may grow up feeling inferior or they might come to believe that violence is an acceptable response to conflict. Time-outs and setting clear rules are recommended by child development experts.
Jahin Sakil
Class X, Al Falah Mission English School, Berhampore
Be patient
Mangoes are born from mango trees. Disciplined parents will be able to rear disciplined children. Parents are the first teachers of children. They have to be patient.
Ahona Sanyal
Class XI, Sarat Kumari Girls’ High School, Santipur, Nadia
Depression
Beating up children to discipline them will lead to unnecessary agression and depression. They would not be able to understand the reason behind such violence.
Pratyusha Bhattacharya
Class VIII, Hariyana Vidya Mandir, Calcutta
Let them explore
Corporal punishment is an illogical and unethical practice. Children can’t learn discipline unless what’s good or bad is explained to them with proper reasoning.
Debarpita Mandi
Class X, DAV Public School,
Midnapore
NEXT ISSUE: INDIA CAN NEVER BEAT CHINA AT THE OLYMPIC GAMES. Have a strong view on this? Write in with your name, school or college, and year to telegraphyou@gmail.com. The best answers for the motion and the most cogent arguments against it will be printed here